Fighting for “polluter pays principle” at Supreme Court

Image by Product of Newfoundland via Flickr

Representing Friends of the Earth before the Supreme Court of Canada, Ecojustice argued that insolvent corporations cannot shift the cost of cleaning up environmental contamination to the taxpayer.

This is the first time Canada’s insolvency procedure has been challenged to deal with the polluter pays principle. In this case, the issue is historic contamination by Abitibibowater Inc.’s mining, shipping and pulp and paper operations in Newfoundland and Labrador.

“Businesses can’t restructure their way out of obligations to remediate the environment,” said William Amos, director of the Ecojustice Clinic at the University of Ottawa. “The system is broken when it forces the environment to line up with creditors and makes Newfoundlanders and Labradorians pay for a mess that Abitibibowater created.”

Abitibibowater operated industrial sites in Newfoundland and Labrador for more than a century until 2008. Its operations have resulted in severe environmental damage, including the deposit of heavy metals and chemicals hazardous to human health into the surrounding lands and waters.

The province subsequently issued orders under the provincial Environmental Protection Act in November 2009, requiring Abitibibowater to perform environmental remediation at a number of its former sites. However, because Abitibibowater had filed for protection under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act, a federal statute, two lower courts said that the company has no obligation to repair the environmental contamination it caused.

“This case has the potential to send a powerful signal to polluters, their bankers and investors on the need to not only disclose but to pay in real time for environmental messes,” says Beatrice Olivastri, CEO, Friends of the Earth Canada.  “Future generations should not bear the costs of yesterday’s and today’s pollution.”

Ecojustice and Friends of the Earth are also concerned that allowing

to shirk its responsibility to clean up its former sites threatens the ability of provincial governments to enforce environmental protection statutes and absolves insolvent corporations of any accountability.

“Insolvency processes should not grant a company a clean slate when it comes to environmental contamination,” Amos said. “Abitibibowater has a new name [Resolute Forest Products], it is restructuring and expects to return to profitability within a few years. Newfoundlanders and Labradorians, on the other hand, are still waiting for those contaminated sites to be cleaned and wondering who will foot the bill.”

Related articles

• N.L. wants AbitibiBowater to pay up (cbc.ca)